Law & Practice
CHINA: Shanghai IP Court Affirms OEM Production Does Not Infringe Domestic Trademark Rights
Published: September 4, 2024
Maggie Yang Brookstone IP Limited Beijing, China INTA Bulletins—China Subcommittee
Verifier
Shirley Kwok King & Wood Mallesons LLP Hong Kong SAR, China INTA Bulletins—China Subcommittee
In a significant ruling, the Shanghai Intellectual Property Court (Shanghai IP Court) has determined that an original equipment manufacturer (OEM) producing goods for export does not infringe on a trademark registered in China. The Court issued its judgment on June 11, 2024.
The case, (2023) Hu 73 Min Zhong No. 475, involved Fuzhou Yamma Electromechanical Co., Ltd. (Fuzhou Yamma), which sued Chongqing Senci Import & Export Trade Co., Ltd. (Chongqing Senci) over the production and export to the United States of a gasoline powered generator bearing the PREDATOR trademark, which Fuzhou Yamma had registered in China.
The first instance court, the Pudong New Area People’s Court of Shanghai, (2021) Hu 0115 Min Chu No. 77928, found that this was a case of “foreign-related OEM” production, where a domestic manufacturer produces goods exclusively for export using an overseas brand owner’s trademark. The Court determined that such OEM production would not cause consumer confusion in China or damage the registered trademark rights of Fuzhou Yamma.
Unsatisfied with the first instance court’s judgment, Fuzhou Yamma appealed to the Shanghai IP Court. After reviewing the case, the appellate court upheld the lower court’s decision.
The Shanghai IP Court explained that for foreign-related OEM production, where the goods are entirely exported, the affixed trademarks would not confuse domestic consumers or undermine the trademark’s identification function registered in China. Hence, the Court concluded that such OEM production generally does not infringe on the exclusive rights of a domestically registered trademark.
However, the Court also acknowledged that this traditional principle of the territorial nature of trademark rights may need to be reexamined on a case-by-case basis, given the increasing trends of cross-border mobility, e-commerce, and Internet globalization.
In this specific case, the appellate court held that the product was merely a sample machine, and there was no evidence of Chongqing Senci selling it in China. The risk of reimportation to China was deemed extremely low, and finding infringement would lead to an imbalance of the interests of the different parties and could have hindered the normal development of the OEM processing industry.
Consequently, the Shanghai IP Court dismissed Fuzhou Yamma’s appeal, upholding the original judgment.
Although every effort has been made to verify the accuracy of this article, readers are urged to check independently on matters of specific concern or interest. Law & Practice updates are published without comment from INTA except where it has taken an official position.
© 2024 International Trademark Association
This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.
To find out more please see our Cookies Policy and Privacy Policy.
These cookies are used to identify a user’s browser as the visitor goes from page to page on the Site. These are session cookies, which means that the cookie is deleted when you leave the Site. It is an integral piece of the Site software and used to let the server know which users are on the Site at any given time and make certain parts of the Site easier to use.
|
|
If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.
These cookies are used to collect information about how visitors use our Site. The cookies collect information in anonymous form, including the numbers of visitors to the Site, where visitors have come to the Site from, the pages they visited and how they have interacted with tools on the Site like search and embedded media players. We use the information to compile statistical reports of our users’ browsing patterns so that we can improve the Site.
|
|
Please enable Functionality Cookies first so that we can save your preferences!
These cookies are used to deliver advertising relevant to the interests of visitors to our Site. They are persistent, which means they will remain on your device after you leave the Site.
- Facebook (Ad Pixel)
- Google (Ad Pixel)
- LinkedIn (Ad Pixel)
- Quattro Anonymous
Please enable Functionality Cookies first so that we can save your preferences!